| ERA | 1.63 | Ramiro Mendoza, American Eagles of Tupelo (2002) |
| G | 36 | Bret Prinz, Mafia (2002) |
| GS | 21 | David Wells, Mafia (2002) |
| CG | 10 | Kevin Brown, Eagles (2000) Pedro Martinez, Tokers (2001) |
| ShO | 4 | Roger Clemens, Brawlers (2001) |
| W | 11 | Kevin Millwood, Diamond Kings (2000) John Smoltz, Mafia (2000) Jamie Moyer, Norsemen (2002) |
| L | 10 | Andy Ashby, Dragons (2000) Rick Helling, Darts (2000) |
| Svs | 15 | Rich Garces, Mafia (2001) Mariano Rivera, Diamond Kings (2001) Billy Wagner, Rockers (1999) Billy Wagner, Rockers (2000) Jose Mesa, Jailbirds (2002) Robb Nen, Eagles (2002) |
| IP | 132.3 | Pedro Martinez, Tokers (2001) |
| H | 115 | Tom Glavine, Dragons (2000) Greg Maddux, Hitmen (2000) |
| R | 75 | Rick Helling, Darts (2000) |
| ER | 70 | Rick Helling, Darts (2000) |
| IBB | 10 | Greg Maddux, Hitmen (2002) |
| TBB | 58 | Chan Ho Park, Hound Dogs (2001) |
| K | 191 | Pedro Martinez, Tokers (2001) |
| HR | 21 | Jose Acevedo, Jailbirds (2002) |
| HB* | 17 | Randy Johnson, Doughnuts (2002) |
| * Hit by pitch stats were not kept for pitchers during 1999. HBP stats are from 2000 - current. | ||